Guwahati  
 
logo
  Guwahati,
North East »» Nagaland CM Zeliang wins floor test comfortably•••Bandh call in Tripura, teacher's death sparks protest•••State »» CM takes part in paddy transplantation ceremony, pitches for double cropping•••Deplorable condition of veterinary sub centre •••Stalemate persists in Tarani Forest Reserve•••National »» Mamata blames Centre for halting nationís growth•••BJP's 'brute majority' stifling opposition: Trinamool MP•••Farooq wants US, China help to resolve Kashmir issue, Rahul says no •••International »» Sushma lied about border, India easy to defeat in war: China •••Israel bans Muslim men under 50 from prayer at Jerusalem mosque•••Pakistanís SC reserves verdict on Panama JIT report•••    
  Home » Op-Ed » Story
 
BJP, CPI-M target Mamata
 

ENEMY'S ENEMY IS FRIEND! 
By Saeed Naqvi
O n the eve of the May 2016 West Bengal Assembly elections, Arun Jaitley shared his campaign experiences with some editors. When he attacked Mamata Bannerjee and the Left-Congress front in equal measure, the crowd’s response was tepid. When he attacked the Trinamool for 60 percent of his speech, there was some applause. But when his speech was 75 percent invective against the Trinamool, the applause was thunderous.
The editor who passed on these “findings” to me was then a key figure in the Kolkata establishment. He was amplifying something he liked to believe. So opposed to Mamata was he that he claimed some credit for helping stitch together what was patently an absurd arrangement: The Congress and the CPI-M would hold hands in Bengal, but fight each other in Kerala. They were trounced.
Jaitley’s unflattering report about Mamata’s electoral fortunes can be easily explained. His meetings, obviously organised by RSS cadres, consisted of crowds who were presumably anti-Mamata. His narrative also revealed that, in charting out a future in Bengal, the BJP saw Mamata as a much more formidable obstacle than the Congress-Left combine.
That outcome is precisely what the BJP is up against, now that Amit Shah is preparing the turf for the 2019 elections. In this framework, how does the communal violence following Basirhat play itself out? First, it must be registered that there have been a dozen or so clashes in the state after Mamata’s re-election. It must be said to the credit of the CPI-M’s 36-year rule: Communal riots were almost non-existent. Some of what is happening now is clearly part of the BJP’s effort to create an atmosphere conducive to communal polarisation. It is difficult to see how the BJP can profit from efforts at Hindu consolidation in a state with anywhere between 30 to 35 percent Muslim population. In the absence of a reliable census, these are the figures most parties privately cite. Promoting communalism would leave this bloc vote consolidated exactly where it is: Behind Mamata.
Considering that this very same vote stood four square behind the CPI-M for 34 years, mostly under the charismatic Chief Ministership of Jyoti Basu, its support for Mamata need not theoretically be seen as permanent.
This probably is the desperate hope the CPI-M nurses. To enhance Mamata’s vulnerabilities it has thrown its lot with the BJP: An enemy’s enemy is my friend.
Just as the self-defeating formula, CPI-M + Congress, for the May 2016 elections was credited to CPI-M General Secretary Sitaram Yechury, the strategy of attacking the Trinamool just when it is in the RSS-BJP line of fire is widely believed to be the line enunciated by former party chief, Prakash Karat.
Quite clearly the party has not yet digested the harsh reality that it was trounced by the Trinamool, that Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee was West Bengal’s Gorbachev. In the rush to reform both had lost control.
The Marxist government’s conflict with peasants in Nandigram in March 2007 set into motion a series of events which ultimately dethroned the CPI-M. Karat’s diagnosis was that the anger of Muslim peasants had been stoked by a combination of Jamiat, Trinamool and Naxalities.
Muslim peasants fearful of losing their lands for a Special Economic Zone was the basis on which CPI-ML groups worked hard to mobilise a powerful movement. Jamiat may have played a role since the peasants were Muslim. The only party in the fray to take electoral advantage was the Trinamool.
It was a masterstroke of political opportunism by Mamata. Having lost the 2006 assembly election, she turned her fortunes around using Singur and Nandigram as fulcrums.
A leader’s political durability in Kolkata can sometimes be measured by political currents in neighbouring states — Tripura, for instance.
Possibly inspired by Mamata’s rise, the President of the Congress in Tripura, Sudip Roy Burman, switched to the Trinamool. But when he saw the Modi wave sweeping across Uttar Pradesh and the TV channels, he turned up in Guwahati to promise support to the BJP’s Presidential candidate Ram Nath Kovind.
Now, Agartala is rife with rumours that six TMC MLAs are likely to join the BJP in the coming weeks. In other words, the BJP, which had no member in the assembly, will suddenly have six.
Tripura has been under CPI-M rule for the past 32 years. But the anti-CPI-M vote mostly rallied around the Congress in the past. As elsewhere in the country (West Bengal too), the Congress has reduced itself to a virtual non-entity in the state. At the grassroots, this space is being occupied by the energetic BJP cadres. Taking a holistic view, these must be seen as some of the chinks in the Trinamool armour. (IANS)
(Saeed Naqvi is a commentator on political and diplomatic affairs. The views expressed are personal. He can be reached on saeednaqvi@hotmail.com)

.
       
Maximum
 
Minimum
 
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
oC
 Arunachal News
Khandu offers 1% free power to RHEP- affected people
State to host 5th NE connectivity Summit next year
No impact of Itanagar bandh, Government terms it failure
Concentrate on education: Chai
 Meghalaya News
PMGSY implementation tardy, admits Chief Minister
HC rejects trade bodies' plea
Respect basic rights, says LJP
MHRC holds awareness meet at Nongpoh
 Northeast News
Nagaland CM Zeliang wins floor test comfortably
Bandh call in Tripura, teacher's death sparks protest
 Cachar News
BJP refutes charges of corruption in quarrying and mining of sand
ACKHSA demands special facility for students of affiliated colleges
BJYM elects new president and secretary
 National News
Mamata blames Centre for halting nationís growth
BJP's 'brute majority' stifling opposition: Trinamool MP
Farooq wants US, China help to resolve Kashmir issue, Rahul says no
AgustaWestland: ED gets five-day custody of Dubai-based director
 International News
Sushma lied about border, India easy to defeat in war: China
Israel bans Muslim men under 50 from prayer at Jerusalem mosque
Pakistanís SC reserves verdict on Panama JIT report
Cow antibodies bring hope for effective AIDS vaccine soon
 State-1
CM takes part in paddy transplantation ceremony, pitches for double cropping
Deplorable condition of veterinary sub centre
Stalemate persists in Tarani Forest Reserve
Fake currency accused jailed for five years
 State-2
Anti Medical Terrorism Day observed
Sonowal to attend annual convention of Seemanta Chetana Mancha at Dhubri
Animals return to KNP as flood situation improves
Prohibitory order at sand mining village in Udalguri
 Local Sports
Double crown for Ishika, Haobam
Third phase ticket sales kicks off
Inter-Regional Handball from tomorrow
 Sports
Geeta Phogat gearing up to deliver her best
Chandimal out of first Test; Herath to lead Sri Lanka
Learning cricket with boys, Harmanpreet towers in women's WC
National Sports University Bill, 2017 establishes National Sports University in Manipur
 Editorial
Neighbourly Bullying?
Rights of the Indigenous
Sainik Schools to wean young in NE away from insurgency
Letters to the Editor
 Op-Ed (Sunday)
BJP, CPI-M target Mamata
Darjeeling planters seek financial support
Faith Without Reason
 
Assam
 
Assam is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Dispur located in the city of Guwahati.
 
more...
Nagaland
 
Nagaland is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Kohima. located in the Guwahati city.
 
more...
Mizoram
 
Mizoram is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Aizwal. located in the Guwahati city.
 
more...
Meghalaya
 
Meghalaya is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Shillong. located in the Guwahati.
 
more...
Manipur
 
Manipur is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Imphal.
 
more...
Tripura
 
Tripura is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Agartala.
 
more...
Arunachal Pradesh
 
Arunachal Pradesh is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Itanagar.
 
more...
Sikkim
 
Sikkim is a northeastern state of India with its capital at Gangtok.
 
more...
Home  |  Guwahati City  |  Editorial  |  International  |  National  |  Business  |  Arunachal  |  Meghalaya   |  Northeast  |  State  |  Cachar  |  Sports   |  Local Sports
 Archive  |  Melange  |  Saturday Fare  |  Junior Sentinel  |  Multilingual  |  About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Advertise with us  |  Dongmusa